Pieter was correct.
It was messing up due to the custom loop I was running on the archive page. I removed the custom loop, and then adjusted the arguments with pre_get_posts.
The strange thing was that, to test if it was this issue, running a custom loop on an archive page was the issue, I removed the archive page, and made a normal page with the custom loop, and I had the same issue.
I’m not sure how the above happened, I was probably just doing something else wrong.
Nevertheless, pagination is working now on my archive page, with the altered main loop.
Related Posts:
- Get the current page URL (including pagination)
- Why is “/page/2/” not working?
- Get current URL (permalink) without /page/{pagenum}/
- Date based URLs for custom posts and pagination
- Adding anchor to paginate_links + Safari anchor bug
- 404 on category.php pagination
- Add ‘articles’ prefix before blog posts url without affecting pagination
- Clean install – Changing permalinks in twentyeleven give 404
- Custom permalink for search and pagination
- wp_logout_url redirects to incorrect page because of pagination
- How to Get Page 2 / Paginated RSS Feed with Custom Permalink Structure?
- next_posts_link URL does not include name of custom post type
- Why is page/2/ not working?
- How to handle paging/pagination with a custom permalink?
- Change permalink structure for pagination only
- Pagination using paginate_links
- Home page Pagination – Other pages do not redirect to home page template
- Pagination url for page template
- problem with pagination in custom permalinks
- Whole site’s pagination not working after rewriting product permalink
- WordPress /page/2 gives 404 when custom permalinks is set to %category%%postname%
- How to get a clean pagination link without variable
- Added .html to Woocommerce permalink but pagination don’t work!
- Pagination links for taxonomy archive page 404 error on every page except first
- WordPress Pagination Not Working After Transfer from Localhost
- Add Custom Pagination Permalink
- Search page Paginations not working
- Pagination is not working, how to trace it properly?
- How to change pagination base from slash to query form?
- Category pagination first link works, remaining don’t
- Getting the terms from “Beautiful Taxonomy Filters” Results ot Integrate into “Ajax Load More”
- Post archive pages bringing me to a 404 page
- How does WordPress handle permalinks?
- Get page permalink without wpurl
- Can I use REST-API on plain permalink format?
- How to change ‘with_front” key from an existing custom post type?
- Make post slug have priority over category slug
- How to stop permalink redirects for a particular slug
- Remove Custom Taxonomy Slug from Permalink
- WordPress Links Not Working After Migration
- Migrating WordPress blog to New Webhosts, something is adding a # and gibberish
- Adding File Extensions to Attachment Page Permalinks
- How to tranform Headlines into linkable permalinks?
- Best way to add internal link in widget
- article pages not displaying on local instance of wordpress site
- breadcrumbs & rel=”nofollow”
- Use Regular Expression to get tag from permalink url during wp_rewrite in generate_rewrite_rules
- Permalinks for pages
- Create unique alphanumeric ID on wp_insert_post
- Programatically changing post’s permalink when identical post type is published
- Exclude / Blacklist Permalinks
- Point domain to different webhost’s subdirectory wordpress
- 404 Error Problems with sCategory Permalink plugin
- Default setting permalink /blog/
- Need help getting my Permalink structure right
- Redirect Uploads Folder to Query Vars in WordPress
- how to link post-thumbnail to original img in a lightbox?
- Get the url of a page template without using the page slug and ID
- flush_rewrite_rules breaks permalinks
- How to show permalink auto when type text in post tiltle?
- Accessing Subdirectories in WordPress Install
- Permalink for custom post type
- Permalinks settings
- Pagination for blog posts reloading same page [closed]
- Changing permalinks structure without loosing SEO
- Change Structure Permalink => Error 404? How to redirect
- Change Buddypress Admin Profile Page Permalink
- how do links move when I move my site?
- Permalink for specific page name
- Permalink for PDF of article
- Comment author url link is wrong? How to change from authors/ to author/
- Why can’t change the permalink of my page/post?
- Direct link to post when multiple categories are selected
- Make custom post available under main domain directly?
- Getting an ID from a URL, why can WP do this itself, but none of of the functions provided get it right?
- Big arabic permalinks not work
- Fix 404 error after changing permalink structure
- How can I set up a secondary permalink structure?
- External PHP file & Pretty Permalink
- Help me fix these crazy attachment page URLs (rewrite?)
- Unable to rename permalink
- WordPress permanent links not working (the weird way)
- How to enable %postname% permalinks on Mac?
- How do I structure my permalinks in WordPress?
- WordPress wildcard route to page
- WordPress Attachment Page URL Rewrite!
- Customize URL for specific tags archive
- Permalink Issue | Too many redirects
- Parent/Child Relationships with Multisites?
- Permalink problem ( Blog posts vs custom post types)
- get_permalink wrongfully returns only year and month and not all the link
- Link to most recent child page
- WordPress permalink still not working (error or not understood?)
- Problem when i configure permalink
- wordpress home is gone
- how to create several url aliases for a page
- Post URL not working according to permalink setting
- Strip category base from URL?
- Does the error “A structure tag is required when using custom permalinks.” mean my permalinks haven’t saved?
- Display the content of another page from a specific URL