Those setting should allow anyone to comment (but they have to enter their name/email). (Side note: I usually uncheck the first two option.).
Perhaps the individual posts have disabled comments? Look down below the post editing area for that checkbox (you might have to enable that area via the ‘screen’ dropdown on the top of the page).
If comments are disabled on an individual post, you shouldn’t see the ‘comment’ area below the post.
It is slightly possible that your theme doesn’t allow comments. Change to one of the default themes to see if the comments area (on a newer post) reappear.
Note that your settings do not allow comments past 60 days, so make sure you are testing on a newer post.
Related Posts:
- How to change the email notification recipient (user) for new comments?
- 3 moderators to approve comment
- How to auto-approve internal pingbacks?
- Exclude internal links from comment moderation?
- Multiple Comment Moderators and Notifications
- Add delete, approve, spam Links to Comments
- Get the number of comments awaiting moderation
- Capability for allowing user to post own comments without moderation
- Why do comment moderators need to have all create/edit/delete toboth posts and pages?
- Community Moderation Plugin for Comments [closed]
- Allow contributors to moderate comments comments on posts they write
- Hold comments for moderation only if user is not logged in
- show if comment is in moderation
- Reject Comments Based on Author Email
- Author can only see own post comment and can moderate
- How to moderate (manually approve) comments of a specific (registered) User
- Comment Moderation and CDN Caching
- WordPress comments – how to check if comment still needs to be approved?
- Why does akismet prevent jetpack comments from appearing in my moderation queue? [closed]
- How Do I Allow Comment Moderation for Other User’s Posts?
- Sending comment notifications to different recipients depending on taxonomy terms
- Who approved a comment, to show up in dashboard
- Comment moderation
- Disable comment moderation in multisite
- Comment Blacklist
- Embed a page within WordPress dashboard?
- comment awaiting moderation
- Customize the new comment notifications sent to the post author after the comment is approved
- How do I comment out a block of tags in XML?
- R: Comment out block of code
- Why do I get comment spam even with Akismet and Captcha?
- What tools are available for managing/writing to WordPress? [closed]
- How to rearrange fields in comment_form()
- setting comments off as default for pages and custom post types?
- Is it possible to pull comments from facebook into your blog?
- Filtering the Admin Comments List to Show Only Comments from the Current User?
- Non-threaded comment replies with link to original comment
- Approve comment hook?
- Commenting in user profile page?
- How to change “You must be logged in to post a comment.”
- comment_post_ID 0 (cannot remove from dashboard)
- Disable comments on all posts/pages
- How do I delete all comments from a specific old blog post?
- Removing the “Website” Field from Comments and Replies?
- Stop WordPress redirecting comment-page-1 to the post page?
- Importing old Disqus comments into WordPress
- How to add a class to the comment submit button?
- How to wrap submit button of comment form with div
- How to enable comments for pending and draft posts?
- Using WordPress’ WYSIWYG for comments
- Enable Submit Comment Without Page Reload (Using Ajax)?
- What for is the table “wp_commentmeta” exactly?
- Getting Post Comments for post ID using WP_Query() and a Custom Loop?
- Add option to disable comments on a per posts basis?
- Resetting comment count
- When importing – failed to import: Invalid post type feedback
- Redirect user to a custom url after submitting the comment
- Paginate result set from $wpdb->get_results()
- Change Comment Author Display Name
- Would switching to InnoDB from MyISAM improve performance of comments table?
- Custom comment type based on thread level
- How to add internal, revision comments to page updates
- How to load and show comments with AJAX instead of pagination?
- Linking to Page Showing Only Comments Without Parent Post
- Comment Reply javascript
- How do we remove the H3 tag for the reply-title I.D
- Comments not appearing at all
- comments reply script not working
- How to display comment form error messages in the same page
- How to deal with small scale comment spam on small commercial sites? [closed]
- What should I do to make generated avatars different for anonymous comments?
- A plugin where users can comment with Facebook or Twitter or OpenID [closed]
- Check If comment author is registered
- Comments screen in backend, how to disable email address of commenter for non admins
- Add comments from the admin panel?
- How can I limit the number of comments per registered user per day?
- One comment per user per post but be able to reply to existing comments
- How to use a custom comments template
- Comment visibility
- What’s the easiest way to close comments on media/attachments?
- Reverse comment pagination numbers
- Get comments for more than one post
- How can I add comments to a page?
- How to remove comment spam in WordPress
- Post Comments using WP REST API v2 in WordPress
- show number of open comments on custom dashboard
- Show content only if member left a comment
- Add placeholder attribute to comment form fields
- Why do I get accidental comments without (the required) email address?
- How is comment spam received without a comments form?
- Does a reply to a wordpress comment notify the author of the comment?
- What are the current recommended best-practices for comments.php?
- human_time_diff() returns “48 years ago” for all comments
- How do I set up real anonymous posting in bbpress forums? [closed]
- Comment Count for each Comment Author
- Link name in comments to Author page? Comment Author Meta in Comments?
- How do I turn off wordpress comments ability to capture a users ip address?
- Showing comments only to same custom user role
- Parent comment’s author name
- Success message in comment form