You cannot change the requirement in a theme, just the presentation of that requirement.
Make the settings in wp-admin/options-discussion.php instead:
Related Posts:
- How do I comment out a block of tags in XML?
- R: Comment out block of code
- How to rearrange fields in comment_form()
- How do I delete all comments from a specific old blog post?
- Removing the “Website” Field from Comments and Replies?
- How to enable comments for pending and draft posts?
- Comments not appearing at all
- A plugin where users can comment with Facebook or Twitter or OpenID [closed]
- Reverse comment pagination numbers
- Comment Count for each Comment Author
- Show comments from multiple post IDs in comment template
- Comment form validation
- Sticky Comments
- Whitelisting Commenters
- WP_Comment_Query() displays “password protected” comments?
- Comments number message in password protected post
- Disable Comments Feed
- Use rich text editor in comments?
- Add a custom class to awating comments
- How to add custom comment fields but *only on the comment reply form*?
- I have tried using Plugins to remove 72K comments with no success
- Show only posts which can be commented
- What should I hook to add extra fields to comments?
- Get a variable field of all comments of current post
- Average Score of all ratings in comments
- Making a Comment on a page without being on that page?
- Warning: call_user_func_array() expects parameter 1 to be a valid callback, func
- How To Disable Comments On New Page
- What is the server IP comment hack
- Do I have to have a nonce for a custom comment field?
- Get last seen date/time in wordpress get_comments() [closed]
- Report spam button
- Recent comments from my blogs only
- show if comment is in moderation
- Disable or Enable Comments on Front end [closed]
- Change username to nickname in comment section
- Hide notifications regarding new comments
- How can I get a list of comments by target
- Load comments.php template outside the post loop
- Auto-fill Custom comment fields
- Highlighting the current users comment
- How to make all the posts commentable by default? Imputs in Settings/Discussions are not saved
- Are there any “YouTube-styled” commenting systems for WordPress?
- How to auto empty comment trash after X days
- comments.php keep comment date/time but remove date/time’s #hyperlink
- how to change comment author’s link from user’s website to author’s page(author.php)?
- Add class to comment form div when comment-reply button is clicked
- Disabling archives, search results, comments, etc?
- Pagination Comments Doesn’t Show
- Display complete comment section via post ID
- WordPress comments – how to check if comment still needs to be approved?
- PAIN. Comments Pagination
- How to retain comment text on comment form after login/registration?
- comments_array filter doesn’t work in some themes
- Redirect when click on “response” in comment section
- Troubleshooting Emoji in Comments
- strange behavior with comment position
- Why could my comment_form variable not be working?
- How to block comments and pings?
- Batch approve comments
- Disable comments and pingbacks on old custom post types
- Can I turn off further comments on a single page?
- How to remove the number of a comment in the url slug?
- How to allow duplicate comments?
- How are readers authenticated for leaving comments?
- Are there some caveats for using guids for FB comments
- How to wrap comment_form $fields in one div?
- How can I grab and show the reader comments of my site
- WordPress comments – delimiter “/” not found
- ask and edit an extra comment field
- How include comment and post count of user in this custom query
- Refresh individual comment text via API
- How to filter comments by comment_meta
- Prevent users to delete comments from trash
- How to display replies to his comments in user profile of current user
- How do I refresh “Post Last Modified Time”, as long as comment is updated to Approve status?
- Top rated posts Average rating issue
- Need to output comment_form() function inside a foreach loop
- stop url changing when user comments
- Comment field override
-   not working in comments
- Badges for Guests based on their comment counts [closed]
- How to add a class to comment submit button?
- WordPress Comments – Only show part of user name
- URLs to user page is broken
- Comments Template shows, but not the comments
- Broken comments section – WordPress 2014 Theme
- Need an advice about comments
- Force logged in users to provide more data when commenting
- How do I get the comments section to show up?
- By Default, Turn Comments Off for Pages & Leave Comments On for Posts
- same comment list for two posts
- Replace do_action() with a normal submit form in comments.php
- Getting thousands of spam comments
- edit-comments.php in Admin – how to change ‘Comments’ title?
- Stop future commenting on specific post
- How to disable comments on new blog post, but allow on new products?
- Customize the new comment notifications sent to the post author after the comment is approved
- Get approved comments or comments that the author is me
- Show/Hide comments