Returning an empty string : efficient way in c++

Gcc 7.1 -O3 these are all identical, godbolt.org/z/a-hc1d – jterm Apr 25 at 3:27

Original answer:

Did some digging. Below is an example program and the relevant assembly:

Code:

#include <string>

std::string get_string1(){ return ""; }

std::string get_string2(){ return std::string(); }

std::string get_string3(){ return {}; }           //thanks  Kerrek SB

int main()
{
    get_string1();
    get_string2();
    get_string3();
}

Assembly:

__Z11get_string1v:
LFB737:
    .cfi_startproc
    pushl   %ebx
    .cfi_def_cfa_offset 8
    .cfi_offset 3, -8
    subl    $40, %esp
    .cfi_def_cfa_offset 48
    movl    48(%esp), %ebx
    leal    31(%esp), %eax
    movl    %eax, 8(%esp)
    movl    $LC0, 4(%esp)
    movl    %ebx, (%esp)
    call    __ZNSsC1EPKcRKSaIcE
    addl    $40, %esp
    .cfi_def_cfa_offset 8
    movl    %ebx, %eax
    popl    %ebx
    .cfi_restore 3
    .cfi_def_cfa_offset 4
    ret $4
    .cfi_endproc

__Z11get_string2v:
LFB738:
    .cfi_startproc
    movl    4(%esp), %eax
    movl    $__ZNSs4_Rep20_S_empty_rep_storageE+12, (%eax)
    ret $4
    .cfi_endproc

__Z11get_string3v:
LFB739:
    .cfi_startproc
    movl    4(%esp), %eax
    movl    $__ZNSs4_Rep20_S_empty_rep_storageE+12, (%eax)
    ret $4
    .cfi_endproc

This was compiled with -std=c++11 -O2.

You can see that there is quite a lot more work for the return ""; statement and comparably little for return std::string and return {}; (these two are identical).

As Frerich Raabe said, when passing an empty C_string, it still needs to do processing on it, instead of just allocating memory. It seems that this can’t be optimised away (at least not by GCC)

So the answer is to definitely use:

return std::string();

or

return {};   //(c++11)

Although unless you are returning a lot of empty strings in performance critical code (logging I guess?), the difference is going to still be insignificant.

Related Posts:

  1. Returning an empty string : efficient way in c++
  2. Why the switch statement cannot be applied on strings?
  3. How to convert string to char array in C++?
  4. How can I convert a std::string to int?
  5. Easiest way to convert int to string in C++
  6. std::string to char*
  7. How to convert string to char array in C++?
  8. C++ — expected primary-expression before ‘ ‘
  9. C++ string to double conversion
  10. Conversion from string to char – c++
  11. What is `CString`?
  12. How do I include the string header?
  13. Differences between C++ string == and compare()?
  14. How do I convert a double into a string in C++?
  15. Split a string using C++11
  16. How do I iterate over the words of a string?
  17. How to convert an instance of std::string to lower case
  18. Check if a string contains a string in C++
  19. How do I iterate over the words of a string?
  20. Replace part of a string with another string
  21. C++ string to double conversion
  22. What is use of c_str function In c++
  23. C++ Parsing input string to variables
  24. std::string to char*
  25. How to convert a std::string to const char* or char*
  26. How do I tokenize a string in C++?
  27. Why use string::iterator rather than index?
  28. Why am I getting string does not name a type Error?
  29. C++ deprecated conversion from string constant to ‘char*’
  30. identifier “string” undefined?
  31. Press Enter to Continue
  32. Converting a vector to string
  33. Parsing a comma-delimited std::string
  34. How can I convert const char* to string and then back to char*?
  35. std::string formatting like sprintf
  36. Sorting Characters Of A C++ String
  37. basic_string::_M_construct null not valid after constructing subvector of strings
  38. How to return a string from a C++ function?
  39. std::out_of_range error?
  40. What is the difference between isdigit() and isnumber()?
  41. Convert char* to string C++
  42. printf with std::string?
  43. Convert a String In C++ To Upper Case
  44. Right way to split an std::string into a vector
  45. Read whole ASCII file into C++ std::string
  46. C++: std does not have member “string”
  47. C++ String Variable Declaration
  48. Split a string into an array in C++
  49. splitting a string into an array in C++ without using vector
  50. Remove spaces from std::string in C++
  51. Remove spaces from std::string in C++
  52. c++ convert string to hex
  53. How can I iterate through a string and also know the index (current position)?
  54. c++ parse int from string [duplicate]
  55. Hash function for a string
  56. C++ strings and pointers
  57. How to Convert a C++ String to Uppercase
  58. std::wstring VS std::string
  59. C++ Simple hangman game
  60. std::cin input with spaces?
  61. Remove First and Last Character C++
  62. C++ Remove punctuation from String
  63. C++ string to enum
  64. C++ Convert string (or char*) to wstring (or wchar_t*)
  65. Static linking vs dynamic linking
  66. C++ – Assigning null to a std::string
  67. How to alphabetically sort strings?
  68. How to get current time in milliseconds?
  69. Hash function for a string
  70. Reading string by char till end of line C/C++
  71. How do I check if a C++ std::string starts with a certain string, and convert a substring to an int?
  72. Fastest way to Convert String to Binary?
  73. Why I cannot cout a string?
  74. How to print a string in C++
  75. Is Python faster and lighter than C++?
  76. std::string length() and size() member functions
  77. How to convert QString to int?
  78. Which is faster C++ String length() or size()?
  79. How do I create a random alpha-numeric string in C++?
  80. Is string::compare reliable to determine alphabetical order?
  81. Trying to use int in getline
  82. error: switch quantity not an integer
  83. Reading a string from file c++
  84. How to change string into QString?
  85. Remove last character from C++ string
  86. Function stoi not declared
  87. Converting String to Cstring in C++
  88. c++ sizeof( string )
  89. How to do std::string indexof in C++ that returns index of matching string?
  90. variable or field declared void
  91. Function stoi not declared
  92. Understanding error “terminate called after throwing an instance of ‘std::length_error’ what(): basic_string::_S_create Aborted (core dumped)”
  93. convert string to size_t
  94. ‘setprecision’ is not a member of ‘std’
  95. Converting bool to text in C++
  96. Why are there two different getline() functions (if indeed there are)?
  97. Why does my program give “NULL used in arithmetic”
  98. How to find and replace string?
  99. Declaration is incompatible with type
  100. I’m getting the error “stoi is not a member of std” in myprogramminglab [duplicate]

Leave a Comment