Why is IoC / DI not common in Python?

I don’t actually think that DI/IoC are that uncommon in Python. What is uncommon, however, are DI/IoC frameworks/containers.

Think about it: what does a DI container do? It allows you to

  1. wire together independent components into a complete application …
  2. … at runtime.

We have names for “wiring together” and “at runtime”:

  1. scripting
  2. dynamic

So, a DI container is nothing but an interpreter for a dynamic scripting language. Actually, let me rephrase that: a typical Java/.NET DI container is nothing but a crappy interpreter for a really bad dynamic scripting language with butt-ugly, sometimes XML-based, syntax.

When you program in Python, why would you want to use an ugly, bad scripting language when you have a beautiful, brilliant scripting language at your disposal? Actually, that’s a more general question: when you program in pretty much any language, why would you want to use an ugly, bad scripting language when you have Jython and IronPython at your disposal?

So, to recap: the practice of DI/IoC is just as important in Python as it is in Java, for exactly the same reasons. The implementation of DI/IoC however, is built into the language and often so lightweight that it completely vanishes.

(Here’s a brief aside for an analogy: in assembly, a subroutine call is a pretty major deal – you have to save your local variables and registers to memory, save your return address somewhere, change the instruction pointer to the subroutine you are calling, arrange for it to somehow jump back into your subroutine when it is finished, put the arguments somewhere where the callee can find them, and so on. IOW: in assembly, “subroutine call” is a Design Pattern, and before there were languages like Fortran which had subroutine calls built in, people were building their own “subroutine frameworks”. Would you say that subroutine calls are “uncommon” in Python, just because you don’t use subroutine frameworks?)

BTW: for an example of what it looks like to take DI to its logical conclusion, take a look at Gilad Bracha‘s Newspeak Programming Language and his writings on the subject:

Related Posts:

  1. Why is IoC / DI not common in Python?
  2. What is dependency injection?
  3. What is Inversion of Control?
  4. What is a JavaBean exactly?
  5. What is a wrapper class?
  6. Is there a simple, elegant way to define singletons? [duplicate]
  7. What are the differences between Abstract Factory and Factory design patterns?
  8. Difference between static class and singleton pattern?
  9. Is dependency injection useful in C++
  10. Is dependency injection useful in C++
  11. What is the difference between Builder Design pattern and Factory Design pattern?
  12. On design patterns: When should I use the singleton?
  13. What is a MV* framework?
  14. Flask-framework: MVC pattern
  15. What’s an Aggregate Root?
  16. (Python) TypeError: ‘float’ object is not subscriptable
  17. LogisticRegression: Unknown label type: ‘continuous’ using sklearn in python
  18. ValueError: Unknown label type: ‘continuous’
  19. Transpose/Unzip Function (inverse of zip)?
  20. TypeError: unhashable type: ‘numpy.ndarray’
  21. python base64 to hex
  22. Relative imports in Python 3
  23. ow can I find where Python is installed on Windows?
  24. Safest way to convert float to integer in python?
  25. Graphviz’s executables are not found (Python 3.4)
  26. What’s the canonical way to check for type in Python?
  27. IndexError: tuple index out of range —– Python
  28. What does it mean if a Python object is “subscriptable” or not?
  29. How to sort with lambda in Python
  30. How do you use subprocess.check_output() in Python?
  31. filename.whl is not a supported wheel on this platform
  32. How to use torch.stack function
  33. (Help) TypeError: ‘str’ object cannot be interpreted as an integer
  34. ‘builtin_function_or_method’ object is not iterable
  35. Why KeyError: 0
  36. bash: pip: command not found
  37. How do I concatenate two lists in Python?
  38. Convert a tensor to numpy array in Tensorflow?
  39. How to run Conda?
  40. How do I check whether a file exists without exceptions?
  41. Python nonlocal statement
  42. How can I get dictionary key as variable directly in Python (not by searching from value)?
  43. How to get the filename without the extension from a path in Python?
  44. How do I detect collision in pygame?
  45. Python AttributeError: ‘module’ object has no attribute ‘SSL_ST_INIT’
  46. Remove all occurrences of a value from a list?
  47. os.path.dirname(__file__) returns empty
  48. keyerror 1 in my code
  49. ‘NoneType’ object has no attribute ‘group’
  50. How to fix ‘ValueError: list.remove(x): x not in list’ error in Python
  51. Count unique values using pandas groupby
  52. Running Bash commands in Python
  53. (unicode error) ‘unicodeescape’ codec can’t decode bytes in position 2-3: truncated \UXXXXXXXX escape
  54. How do you split a list into evenly sized chunks?
  55. Ignoring NaNs with str.containsv
  56. How to split a string into a list of characters in Python?
  57. Find where python is installed (if it isn’t default dir)
  58. log2 in python math module
  59. Is there an operation for not less than or not greater than in python?
  60. python ZeroDivisionError: float division by zero – how to treat it as an exception
  61. Playing mp3 song on python
  62. Unresolved reference issue in PyCharm
  63. Python Library Path
  64. .pyw files in python program
  65. Get the cartesian product of a series of lists?
  66. No module named googlesamples.assistant.auth_helpers
  67. Solution for SpecificationError: nested renamer is not supported while agg() along with groupby()
  68. Why is there no tuple comprehension in Python?
  69. pip: no module named _internal
  70. Image.open() cannot identify image file – Python?
  71. python socket programming OSError: [WinError 10038] an operation was attempted on something that is not a socket
  72. python math domain errors in math.log function
  73. Append a dictionary to a dictionary
  74. How to install Python MySQLdb module using pip?
  75. Fast ping sweep in python
  76. Error “‘type’ object has no attribute ‘__getitem__'” when iterating over list[“a”,”b”,”c”]
  77. Python: “TypeError: __str__ returned non-string” but still prints to output?
  78. ImportError: No module named ‘django.core.urlresolvers’
  79. Numpy, multiply array with scalar
  80. Python 3: Multiply a vector by a matrix without NumPy
  81. How to fix “Can’t find a default Python” error
  82. TypeError: ‘newline’ is an invalid keyword argument for this function
  83. datetime to string with series in pandas
  84. What is the difference between random.randint and randrange?
  85. How do I access my webcam in Python?
  86. Boolean Series key will be reindexed to match DataFrame index
  87. What is the easiest way to clear a database from the CLI with manage.py in Django?
  88. Printing one character at a time from a string, using the while loop
  89. Change the name of a key in dictionary
  90. Check if an object exists
  91. How do I calculate the date six months from the current date using the datetime Python module?
  92. How to embed image or picture in jupyter notebook, either from a local machine or from a web resource?
  93. TypeError: can only concatenate tuple (not “int”) in Python
  94. Write a program using integers user_num and x as input, and output user_num divided by x three times
  95. Logical operators for Boolean indexing in Pandas
  96. Transposing a 1D NumPy array
  97. Explaining Python’s ‘__enter__’ and ‘__exit__’
  98. numpy.float64 object is not iterable…but I’m NOT trying to
  99. Converting a list to a set changes element order
  100. How do you fetch the authors email or IP from /comments? (REST API)

Leave a Comment

error code: 523