Some simple php, check if it’s set before trying to unset it.
function my_filter_plugin_updates( $value ) {
if( isset( $value->response['duplicator/duplicator.php'] ) )
unset( $value->response['duplicator/duplicator.php'] ); //Duplicator
return $value;
}
add_filter( 'site_transient_update_plugins', 'my_filter_plugin_updates' );