Should network hardware be set to “autonegotiate” speeds or fixed speeds?

  1. I have yet to see a problem with auto-negotiation of network speeds that isn’t caused by either (a) a mismatch of manual on one end of the link and auto on the other or (b) a failing component of the link (cable, port, etc).

  2. This depends on the admin, but my experience has shown me that if you manually specify the link speeds and duplex settings, than you are bound to run into speed mismatches. Why? Because it is nearly impossible to document the various connections between switches and servers and then follow that documentation when making changes. Most failures I have seen are because of 1(a) and you only get in to that situation when you start manually setting speed/duplex settings.

As mention in the Cisco documentation:

If you disable autonegotiation, it hides link drops and other physical layer problems. Only disable autonegotiation to end-devices, such as older Gigabit NICs that do not support Gigabit autonegotiation. Do not disable autonegotiation between switches unless absolutely required, as physical layer problems can go undetected and result in spanning tree loops.

Unless you are prepared to setup a change management system for network changes that requires the verification of speed/duplex (and don’t forget flow control) or are willing to deal with occasional mismatches that come from manually specifying these settings on all network devices, then stick with the default configuration of auto/auto.

In the future, consider monitoring the errors on the switch ports with MRTG so you can spot these issues before you have a problem.

Edit: I do see a lot of people referencing negotiation failures on old equipment. Yes this was an issue a long time ago when the standards were being created and not all devices followed them. Are your NICs and switches less than 10 years old? If so, then this won’t be an issue.

Related Posts:

  1. How do VLANs work?
  2. What does localhost:8080 mean?
  3. Is it possible to repeat or redistribute a Bluetooth signal? [closed]
  4. java.net.ConnectException: Connection refused
  5. How can you find out which process is listening on a TCP or UDP port on Windows?
  6. java.net.ConnectException :connection timed out: connect?
  7. What is the difference between a port and a socket?
  8. Does TCP send a SYN/ACK on every packet or only on the first connection?
  9. Finding local IP addresses using Python’s stdlib
  10. Docker-compose container using host DNS server
  11. UDP vs TCP, how much faster is it?
  12. Android check internet connection
  13. How does IPv4 Subnetting Work?
  14. I’ve inherited a rat’s nest of cabling. What now?
  15. What is the difference between Unix sockets and TCP/IP sockets?
  16. Why couldn’t MAC addresses be used instead of IPv4|6 for networking? [closed]
  17. VirtualBox: How to set up networking so both host and guest can access internet and talk to each other
  18. What causes the ‘Connection Refused’ message?
  19. How does IPv6 subnetting work and how does it differ from IPv4 subnetting?
  20. Why do consoles sometimes hang forever when SSH connection breaks?
  21. Switching to IPv6 implies dropping NAT. Is that a good thing?
  22. How much network latency is “typical” for east – west coast USA?
  23. How do I find if there is a rogue DHCP server on my Network?
  24. Is X.Y.Z.0 a valid IP address?
  25. ssh tunnel refusing connections with “channel 2: open failed”
  26. How do I make a connection private on Windows Server 2012 R2
  27. What is “anycast” and how is it helpful?
  28. What happens when you plug two sides of a cable to a single networking device?
  29. How to reload default Mac OSX routing table without rebooting
  30. How to check the physical status of an ethernet port in Linux?
  31. ping response “Request timed out.” vs “Destination Host unreachable”
  32. An existing connection was forcibly closed by the remote host
  33. Chrome hangs after certain amount of data transfered – waiting for available socket
  34. Connect: Socket operation on non-socket
  35. Connect: Socket operation on non-socket
  36. Networking with C++
  37. Socket Programming in C++
  38. ssh: Could not resolve hostname [hostname]: nodename nor servname provided, or not known
  39. The RPC server is unavailable. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x800706BA)
  40. Will setting a multicast destination address to FFFF.FFFF.FFFF make it a broadcast?
  41. How do I resolve the “java.net.BindException: Address already in use: JVM_Bind” error?
  42. Command line for looking at specific port
  43. Best C/C++ Network Library
  44. java.net.SocketException: Connection reset
  45. Unity3D. Trying to send command for object without authority
  46. Sending string via socket (python)
  47. HTTP Status 500 Error instantiating servlet class
  48. What is the quickest way to HTTP GET in Python?
  49. Where to find the complete definition of off_t type?
  50. Bridged networking not working in Virtualbox under Windows 10
  51. Socket.Select returns error “An operation was attempted on something that is not a socket”
  52. wget: unable to resolve host address `http’
  53. Regular expression that matches valid IPv6 addresses
  54. How do I get Flask to run on port 80?
  55. Get local IP address
  56. Level vs Edge Trigger Network Event Mechanisms
  57. Setting the hostname: FQDN or short name?
  58. Should I quit using Ifconfig?
  59. Resolve host name from IP address
  60. In Windows, using the command line, how do you check if a remote port is open?
  61. How to forcibly close a socket in TIME_WAIT?
  62. How to check if a port is blocked on a Windows machine?
  63. What is this IP address: 169.254.169.254?
  64. How to determine the hostname from an IP address in a Windows network?
  65. SSHFS mount that survives disconnect
  66. How to get TX/RX bytes without ifconfig?
  67. Testing UDP port connectivity

Leave a Comment