lvalue required as left operand of assignment – Array

The error is actually “lvalue required as left operand of assignment”.

It means that your a[i][j] is giving you a temporary object. This happens when you return from a function by value. A function call that returns by value is an rvalue expression, and you cannot use an rvalue expression as the left operand of an assignment. You need to change the implementation of operator[] on both the Matrix and the helper class that Matrix::operator[] returns so that they return by reference. A function call that returns by reference is an lvalue expression and will allow you to assign to it.

template <typename T>
Vector<T>& Matrix<T>::operator[](int index) { ... }
template <typename T>
T& Vector<T>::operator[](int index) { ... }

Of course, this makes sense. If your operator[]s didn’t return by reference, how would assigning to the value returned by them have any effect on the contents of the Matrix?

In response to your edit:

You have a problem with the design of your class. The Matrix class appears to store a 3-by-3 array of floats called coords. However, when you use Matrix::operator[], it copies the values from a row of coords into a Vector object. They are copies. You then return that Vector by value, which copies the Vector and its contained values out of the function. Anything you do to that returned Vector will only affect that copy.

In addition to this, your switch statement is totally pointless. Every case is exactly the same. You just need to use i as the array indices and not switch on it.

Also, if you’re going to allow people that call operator[] to modify the contents of your Matrix, then the operator[] function must not be const.

There are a few alternatives that will fix your problem. The first is to just return a float* instead and scrap your plan with Vector:

float* Matrix::operator[](int i) {
    return coords[i];
}

That’s a very simple solution but does involve passing a raw pointer around. The raw pointer can be used like an array, allowing you the syntax m[i][j].

You could do the same as the Eigen library and instead provide a operator() that takes two arguments, the row index and column index:

float& Matrix::operator()(int i, int j) {
    return coords[i][j];
}

Note that the float is being returned by reference: float&. This means that is modifiable from outside the call to operator(). Here, you would index a row and column with m(i, j).

Related Posts:

  1. How to dynamically allocate arrays in C++
  2. How to dynamically allocate arrays in C++
  3. How do I find the length of an array?
  4. Initializing an array of objects
  5. Passing an array by reference
  6. Return array in a function
  7. Passing an array by reference
  8. How to convert a char array to a string?
  9. What is the array form of ‘delete’?
  10. Use new operator to initialise an array
  11. How do I declare a 2d array in C++ using new?
  12. Is there a function to copy an array in C/C++?
  13. Cleanest way to copy a constant size array in c++11
  14. Reverse Contents in Array
  15. C++ error: “Array must be initialized with a brace enclosed initializer”
  16. warning: ISO C++ forbids variable length array
  17. c++ array – expression must have a constant value
  18. Error while overloading operator (must be a nonstatic member function)
  19. Passing a 2D array to a C++ function
  20. Static array vs. dynamic array in C++
  21. How to create a dynamically-allocated array of const objects, but have values assigned to them?
  22. Fill array with random numbers within a specified range (C++)
  23. Remove an array element and shift the remaining ones
  24. How to make an array with a dynamic size? General usage of dynamic arrays (maybe pointers too)?
  25. How to add element to C++ array?
  26. How to convert vector to array
  27. How to find the size of an int[]?
  28. C++: Expression must have a constant value when declaring array inside function
  29. splitting a string into an array in C++ without using vector
  30. What’s the syntax for declaring an array of function pointers without using a separate typedef?
  31. error: ‘ostream’ does not name a type
  32. Printing an array in C++?
  33. Delete 2D array C++
  34. error: overloaded ‘operator<<' must be a binary operator (has 3 parameters)
  35. How do you initialise a dynamic array in C++?
  36. C++ array assign error: invalid array assignment
  37. How to add element to C++ array?
  38. Reading from .txt file into two dimensional array in c++
  39. extended initializer lists only available with
  40. Creation of Dynamic Array of Dynamic Objects in C++
  41. how to initialize an empty integer array in c++
  42. Check if C++ Array is Null
  43. Correct way to work with vector of arrays
  44. Resizing dynamic array in c++
  45. C++ Initializing a Global Array
  46. Comparing the values of char arrays in C++
  47. Dynamically allocated string array, then change it’s value?
  48. How can I assign an array from an initializer list?
  49. How do I return a char array from a function?
  50. creating an array of structs in c++
  51. Reading data from file into an array
  52. How to read lines of text from file and put them into an array
  53. Why can’t we pass arrays to function by value?
  54. Double pointer array in c++
  55. C++ pass an array by reference
  56. C++ operator+ and operator+= overloading
  57. How to memset char array with null terminating character?
  58. creating dynamic array of string c++
  59. creating an array of structs in c++
  60. C++ Array of pointers: delete or delete []?
  61. too many initializers for ‘int [0]’ c++
  62. operator << must take exactly one argument
  63. C++ 2d char array to string
  64. Using cin for char array
  65. C++ correct way to return pointer to array from function
  66. Warning: comparison of distinct pointer types
  67. how to find 2d array size in c++
  68. Getting error “array bound is not an integer constant before ‘]’ token”
  69. Using cin to input a single letter into a char
  70. Different ways to deallocate an array – c++
  71. Is C++ Array passed by reference or by pointer?
  72. Proper way to pass dynamic arrays to other functions
  73. Array of Linked Lists C++
  74. C++ float array initialization 
  75. Regular cast vs. static_cast vs. dynamic_cast
  76. What is an unsigned char?
  77. C++ std::priority_queue uses the lambda expression
  78. When to use reinterpret_cast?
  79. Expression must be a modifiable lvalue
  80. How do I generate a random number between two variables that I have stored?
  81. How to print pthread_t
  82. make: g++: Command not found
  83. What is an ‘undeclared identifier’ error and how do I fix it?
  84. Converting a vector to string
  85. std::string formatting like sprintf
  86. libpng warning: iCCP: known incorrect sRGB profile
  87. What does ‘const static’ mean in C and C++?
  88. Debug vs Release in CMake
  89. C++ Matrix Class
  90. access violation reading location c++
  91. C++ template constructor
  92. PlaySound in C++ Console application?
  93. c++ reading csv file
  94. Why do you use typedef when declaring an enum in C++?
  95. How well is Unicode supported in C++11?
  96. The CXX compiler identification is unknown
  97. Make / gcc cryptic error 2: how to have more information?
  98. REGSVR32: the module “xxxxx.dll” failed to load … dependent assembly could not be found
  99. Error: expression cannot be used as a function?
  100. What is a .h.gch file?

Leave a Comment