OpenVPN vs. IPsec – Pros and cons, what to use?

I have all of the scenarios setup in my environment. (openvpn site-site, road warriors; cisco ipsec site-site, remote users)

By far the openvpn is faster. The openvpn software is less overhead on the remote users. The openvpn is/can be setup on port 80 with tcp so that it passes at places that have limited free internet. The openvpn is more stable.

Openvpn in my environment does not force policy to the end user. Openvpn key distribution is a little harder to do securely. Openvpn key passwords are up to the end users (they can have blank passwords). Openvpn is not approved by certain auditors (the ones that only read bad trade rags). Openvpn takes a little bit of brains to setup (unlike cisco).

This is my experience with openvpn: I know that most of my negatives can be alleviated through either configuration changes or process changes. So take all my negatives with a bit of skepticism.

Leave a Comment