Plugin redirects URL structure using 301 redirect. Time to disable the plugin?

It’s safe to disable the plugin since you no longer see the old URLs in the index.

To be even safer I recommend doing the following:

  1. submit a sitemap containing only the new URLs
  2. make sure that all inbound links use the new URLs.
  3. create a custom 404 page which mimics your sitemap. This is in case your backlinks uses the old URLs. You would want to send the user a friendly page to help them find what they are looking for.
  4. Help the Google robot by having the correct canonical tags.

EDIT on handling old URL and backlinks you want to preserve:

I had a chat with an SEO consultant about your matter and here is a possible course of action:

The main solution is being able to handle traffic coming from a referring link on an external site and handling an old indexed link coming from search, then trying to come up with an elegant WordPress solution for it.

The first step is to go into Google Analytics and figure out which links are the most landed on both traffic mediums and to do that you will have to create an Advanced Segment, located on the upper right of the reporting profile. Once there you would have to create:

Traffic Sources > Medium "Matches Exactly" > referral
Traffic Sources > Medium "Matches Exactly" > organic

Once you’ve created both go to the Content > Top Landing Pages and look at the top 15 to 20 pages on the report. Sort through the list and find out which ones are 404’s and the next solution would be different for both traffic mediums.

For Referral traffic, you would have to create a rule where if visitors came from a Referring site and the content doesn’t exist, point it to the best relevant content based on text on the referring URL from the visitors cookie, which would be a Search Results Page (SRP) on WordPress. Now this is a complicated but elegant solution. If you can’t pull this off, just create a rule on the mod server file to handle x amount of visitors landing on old page to land on new page.

For Organic traffic, which would be slightly easier to handle, you would have to get the original keyword that brought the visitor to the old indexed link from the search engine and then pass that value over to the WordPress content search engine, in essence landing them on a SRP page. You must be careful though to only do this for links that doesn’t exist anymore and if the visitor came from search.

What’s the best way to figure this out? Manipulating and using the GA cookie values. The GA tag is smart enough to define where the visitor came from and what medium, to see this download and install Firebug (or any HTTP debugger). Look for the GET request being kicked off by the __utm.gif file (the GA tracking pixel), then look at the values. You would see from a parameter list how your visit (or anyone else’s) are being identified by GA.

Related Posts:

  1. Have WordPress post redirect to url when accesed from iPad (Safari)
  2. Redirect Restricted Page to 404
  3. Redirect user to original url after login?
  4. Redirect to dashboard after login
  5. Make a video post redirect to next post after completion
  6. Redirect blog page to latest post?
  7. WordPress site redirects to different wordpress domain on the same server after reuploading db backup
  8. WordPress Redirect based on the prescence of a cookie
  9. Links to an exisiting Page are now redirecting to a draft page?
  10. Random and Erroneous WordPress Redirect
  11. Redirect Old domain & posts to new domain homepage
  12. Redirecting users to referrer page after logging in using custom login form
  13. Remove lost password form and URL
  14. add_rewrite_rule to pass entire path as a single parameter
  15. What is the wordpress way of displaying local external content?
  16. How To Only Allow Users To View Their Own Buddypress Profiles? [closed]
  17. htaccess redirect dynamic posts
  18. Menu links only using http after enabling https, unable to redirect http links
  19. Redirect all pages to homepage but still allow dashboard
  20. some url does not redirect from http to https
  21. Why can’t I access files / directories outside of wordpress
  22. Return to where the user was, after log out
  23. How do I map a subdomain in wordpress to the primary domain in a multisite setup?
  24. Redirect the non-www version of the site to the www
  25. Load time cost of using a redirect plugin v direct .htaccess entry
  26. How to pass email values from one php page to another
  27. How to redirect after login getting a variable from url (for example with the language)
  28. How to set 301 redirection after moving WordPress blog?
  29. How to include error message on login
  30. How to use a custom domain?
  31. Changing siteurl and homeurl – internal links redirect to home page?
  32. WooCommerce unexpected behavior [closed]
  33. Force WordPress to load from site’s hostname
  34. redirect Login problems
  35. 301 redirection editing .htaccess doesn’t work
  36. How can I force the user to log in, even if they’re already authenticated?
  37. 301 redirect instead of 404 when URL is a prefix of a post or page name?
  38. 301-redirect directives for blogger to wordpress migration
  39. Redirect users after register (first login) and force submit post
  40. Some admin pages redirecting to front page on save
  41. How to pass a message using template_redirect
  42. .htaccess 301 redirect conflict with plugin “WordPress Https”
  43. Disable WordPress URL auto complete
  44. How do I put up a splash page and have all WordPress links redirect to this page?
  45. How can I disable author pages without 301 redirects?
  46. Redirect specific URL before other redirects take place in .htaccess?
  47. Redirect Main Home Page url to category URL without plugin
  48. Stop forcing certain paths to end with a forward slash
  49. Force 404 redirect to home?
  50. Redirection on Custom page
  51. How do I redirect users after submitting a topic for moderation?
  52. Direct iPhone visitors to different stylesheet?
  53. 301 redirect any RSS feed on level up url
  54. Redirect loop with similar URLs
  55. Why does WP HTTP API switch the method (POST/PURGE) to GET when redirecting (302)?
  56. Redirect user to specific link after login
  57. 301 redirect via htaccess rules on the new site
  58. WordPress Domain redirects to different host
  59. Change the domain url?
  60. After retrive password, redirect to index page
  61. Change Category Slug Redirection
  62. custom login form redirect problem
  63. WordPress redirect to new domain name
  64. Blog post is redirecting to home page
  65. Trying to re-direct users to specific page based on an ACF variable
  66. Bulk redirect all post
  67. Disable redirect to homepage after successful Login, Stay on Current Page
  68. WordPress no permission redirection to a popup
  69. Open wordpress page in directory the way index.html would open
  70. How force WordPress redirect to current custom page after login
  71. How to remove redirection
  72. Redirect Homepage to another page when user login
  73. Site using static homepage, redirects (301) and removes pluses from query string
  74. Unusual Apache2 Error Causing WordPress Redirect Error?
  75. Redirect error after updating WordPress to 5.4.2
  76. Determine user destination on wp-login.php
  77. 301 Redirect Loop www to non-www – Nginx + Apache2
  78. how to redirect 404 to attachment.php?
  79. 301 Redirect in WordPress not working in htaccess
  80. Toggle Redirect Function On/Off With Checkbox
  81. My wordpress site has “https://” on it but when I go to Dashboard and click visit site, it removes the “https://”
  82. After disabling Multisite, homepage redirects to non-existing page
  83. redirect to https://my-site/wp-admin/ instead of https://my-site/wordpress/wp-admin/ after options updating
  84. Redirect after login when WordPress in subdirectory
  85. I get “too many redirects” problem when migrating localhost site
  86. How to redirect non-admin/editors from specific pages?
  87. How to make a redirect link in wordpress?
  88. wp_redirect leading to an infinite loop
  89. Redirect after Permalink change – What regex do I use?
  90. Configure WordPress to listen on a port other than 80
  91. Do I need to keep the original page when 301 redirecting to a new one?
  92. Redirect based on $_GET parameters
  93. Conditional redirection with logout
  94. Logging back into WordPress after logging out and having issues with ‘loggedout=true’ in redirect URL
  95. redirect users to the login page
  96. How to make my homepage automatically redirect to an external website?
  97. How does the flow of htaccess files in sub-directories work
  98. Redirect to a subdirectory frontpage using without using a WP plugin- what files to edit, and how?
  99. How to Show different page URL instead of default home page URL
  100. Stopping media file redirects