What are the most widely used C++ vector/matrix math/linear algebra libraries, and their cost and benefit tradeoffs?

There are quite a few projects that have settled on the Generic Graphics Toolkit for this. The GMTL in there is nice – it’s quite small, very functional, and been used widely enough to be very reliable. OpenSG, VRJuggler, and other projects have all switched to using this instead of their own hand-rolled vertor/matrix math.

I’ve found it quite nice – it does everything via templates, so it’s very flexible, and very fast.

Edit:

After the comments discussion, and edits, I thought I’d throw out some more information about the benefits and downsides to specific implementations, and why you might choose one over the other, given your situation.

GMTL –

Benefits: Simple API, specifically designed for graphics engines. Includes many primitive types geared towards rendering (such as planes, AABB, quatenrions with multiple interpolation, etc) that aren’t in any other packages. Very low memory overhead, quite fast, easy to use.

Downsides: API is very focused specifically on rendering and graphics. Doesn’t include general purpose (NxM) matrices, matrix decomposition and solving, etc, since these are outside the realm of traditional graphics/geometry applications.

Eigen –

Benefits: Clean API, fairly easy to use. Includes a Geometry module with quaternions and geometric transforms. Low memory overhead. Full, highly performant solving of large NxN matrices and other general purpose mathematical routines.

Downsides: May be a bit larger scope than you are wanting (?). Fewer geometric/rendering specific routines when compared to GMTL (ie: Euler angle definitions, etc).

IMSL –

Benefits: Very complete numeric library. Very, very fast (supposedly the fastest solver). By far the largest, most complete mathematical API. Commercially supported, mature, and stable.

Downsides: Cost – not inexpensive. Very few geometric/rendering specific methods, so you’ll need to roll your own on top of their linear algebra classes.

NT2 –

Benefits: Provides syntax that is more familiar if you’re used to MATLAB. Provides full decomposition and solving for large matrices, etc.

Downsides: Mathematical, not rendering focused. Probably not as performant as Eigen.

LAPACK –

Benefits: Very stable, proven algorithms. Been around for a long time. Complete matrix solving, etc. Many options for obscure mathematics.

Downsides: Not as highly performant in some cases. Ported from Fortran, with odd API for usage.

Personally, for me, it comes down to a single question – how are you planning to use this. If you’re focus is just on rendering and graphics, I like Generic Graphics Toolkit, since it performs well, and supports many useful rendering operations out of the box without having to implement your own. If you need general purpose matrix solving (ie: SVD or LU decomposition of large matrices), I’d go with Eigen, since it handles that, provides some geometric operations, and is very performant with large matrix solutions. You may need to write more of your own graphics/geometric operations (on top of their matrices/vectors), but that’s not horrible.

Related Posts:

  1. Vector of Vectors to create matrix
  2. Error: “expression must have integral or unscoped enum type” [duplicate]
  3. 1e-9 or -1e9, which one is correct?
  4. A proper way to create a matrix in c++
  5. warning: ISO C++ forbids variable length array
  6. C++ Matrix Class
  7. Debug Assertion Failed: _CrtIsValidHeapPointer(block)
  8. Converting from Radians to Degrees
  9. Is there a standard sign function (signum, sgn) in C/C++?
  10. Finding square root without using sqrt function?
  11. Direct way of computing clockwise angle between 2 vectors
  12. How do I build a graphical user interface in C++? [closed]
  13. What are the differences between a pointer variable and a reference variable in C++?
  14. outputting ascii table in C++
  15. What is the effect of extern “C” in C++?
  16. What exactly is the difference between “pass by reference” in C and in C++?
  17. What is `CString`?
  18. Difference between != and =! with an example(in C++)
  19. Unresolved external symbol in object files
  20. How do sizeof(arr) / sizeof(arr[0]) work?
  21. When should I write the keyword ‘inline’ for a function/method?
  22. When does a process get SIGABRT (signal 6)?
  23. Logical XOR operator in C++?
  24. C++ – Decimal to binary converting
  25. Alternative to itoa() for converting integer to string C++?
  26. Returning an empty string : efficient way in c++
  27. invalid conversion from ‘const char*’ to ‘char*’
  28. Evaluate a string with a switch in C++ [duplicate]
  29. Expected initializer before function name
  30. Inheriting constructors
  31. Pass a vector by reference C++
  32. lvalue required as left operand of assignment – Array
  33. What is uintptr_t data type
  34. Why do we use volatile keyword? [duplicate]
  35. C++ round a double up to 2 decimal places
  36. Windows 7 exception code: 0xc0000409
  37. Convert float to std::string in C++
  38. What is the printf format specifier for bool?
  39. libpng warning: iCCP: known incorrect sRGB profile
  40. In CLion, header only library: file “does not belong to any project target, code insight features might not work properly”
  41. Is a function definition not allowed here before a ‘{‘ token?
  42. terminate called after throwing an instance of ‘std::out_of_range’
  43. What does “missing template argument” mean?
  44. undefined reference to ‘std::cout’
  45. warning: control may reach end of non-void function
  46. Error at constructor : Expected an identifier?
  47. Defining a struct in flex error C++
  48. C++ Postfix calculator using stacks
  49. LNK1168: cannot open debug\file.exe for writing
  50. what does “error : a nonstatic member reference must be relative to a specific object” mean?
  51. Can I output a one channel image acquired from camera into a winAppi window?
  52. Difference in make_shared and normal shared_ptr in C++
  53. How to convert C++ Code to C
  54. how to convert C# to C++
  55. What are helper functions in C++?
  56. How to fix ‘std::logic_error’ what(): basic_string::_M_construct null not valid error?
  57. C++ String Variable Declaration
  58. How to fix ‘std::logic_error’ what(): basic_string::_M_construct null not valid error?
  59. Copy a file in a sane, safe and efficient way
  60. c++ convert string to hex
  61. LINK : fatal error LNK1561: entry point must be defined ERROR IN VC++
  62. Multiple OR or AND conditions in IF statement
  63. What does it mean double free detected in tcache 2 while using mpz?
  64. fatal error LNK1169: one or more multiply defined symbols found in game programming
  65. How to initialize a vector of pointers
  66. C++: Using ifstream with getline();
  67. How to add element to C++ array?
  68. c++ Read from .csv file
  69. Check if C++ Array is Null
  70. Random not declared in scope
  71. What does the “Expected ‘(‘ for function-style cast or type construction” error mean?
  72. LINK : fatal error LNK1561: entry point must be defined ERROR IN VC++
  73. Comparing the values of char arrays in C++
  74. Win32 Console Application
  75. What does the fpermissive flag do?
  76. Convert char array to single int?
  77. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3865946/error-generic-array-creation
  78. Does C++11 have C#-style properties?
  79. How to print a string in C++
  80. Creating an instance of class
  81. Destructor for a doubly-linked list that points to its value
  82. cin.ignore(numeric_limits::max(), ‘\n’)
  83. LLVM Compiler 2.0: Warning with “using namespace std;”
  84. C++ operator+ and operator+= overloading
  85. In c++ what does a tilde “~” before a function name signify?
  86. C++ Void Function with File Stream Error
  87. not declared in this scope’ when using strlen()
  88. Converting a Cubemap into Equirectangular Panorama
  89. Why is this vector iterator not incrementable?
  90. glibc detected : double free or corruption
  91. What is the best way to develop a C++ web application?
  92. How to install Visual Studio Build Tools 2010 on Visual Studio 2015 Community?
  93. Throwing out of range exception in C++
  94. Is null reference possible?
  95. compare and swap vs test and set
  96. Weighted random numbers
  97. compare and swap vs test and set
  98. Link error “undefined reference to `__gxx_personality_v0′” and g++ [duplicate]
  99. How to use bitmask?
  100. -Error reading characters of string

Leave a Comment

tech