Why write script type=”text/javascript” when the mime type is set by the server?

Douglas Crockford says:

type="text/javascript"

This attribute is optional. Since Netscape 2, the default programming language in all browsers has been JavaScript. In XHTML, this attribute is required and unnecessary. In HTML, it is better to leave it out. The browser knows what to do.

He also says:

W3C did not adopt the language attribute, favoring instead a type attribute which takes a MIME type. Unfortunately, the MIME type was not standardized, so it is sometimes "text/javascript" or "application/ecmascript" or something else. Fortunately, all browsers will always choose JavaScript as the default programming language, so it is always best to simply write <script>. It is smallest, and it works on the most browsers.

For entertainment purposes only, I tried out the following five scripts

  <script type="application/ecmascript">alert("1");</script>
  <script type="text/javascript">alert("2");</script>
  <script type="baloney">alert("3");</script>
  <script type="">alert("4");</script>
  <script >alert("5");</script>

On Chrome, all but script 3 (type="baloney") worked. IE8 did not run script 1 (type="application/ecmascript") or script 3. Based on my non-extensive sample of two browsers, it looks like you can safely ignore the type attribute, but that it you use it you better use a legal (browser dependent) value.

Leave a Comment