After some experimentation with the settings, I got it working as I wanted it to. Under WordPress Discussion Settings, under the “Email me whenever” subsection, uncheck “anyone posts a comment”.
Related Posts:
- Send Notifications to All Admins
- How to change the email notification recipient (user) for new comments?
- If new comment posted in custom post – send notification to custom email from custom field
- Disable Admin account being emailed for comment notification
- WordPress comments email notification for authors
- Reply By Email to comment notifications
- Not receiving any e-mails after new comment
- Comment notification not working
- Subscribe to a post’s comments without posting a comment yourself
- How to disable the “Your site has updated to WordPress x.y.z” admin email?
- How to add internal, revision comments to page updates
- What’s the easiest way to close comments on media/attachments?
- How can I edit the email sent when a new comment is received?
- Multiple Comment Moderators and Notifications
- Plugin from WordPress.com for comment notification…available? [closed]
- Report spam button
- Follow-up Comments Notification Without a Plug-in
- Reject Comments Based on Author Email
- Filter In Reply comments from WordPress Admin Panel
- Same email for all comments
- Error While Sending Comment
- Notify admin on new submit
- Email notification to an email address other than admin for custom type post comments in wordpress
- Notify post author for a new comment on his post?
- warnCommentChanges always being triggered on update
- How can the recipients and content for comment email notifications on a custom post type be changed?
- comment reply by email
- Notify comment author upon reply
- How can I get list of emails of users who commented on a post?
- Sent comments notifications to multiple users
- Sending comment notifications to different recipients depending on taxonomy terms
- How to get Post title by locale with Qtranslate-X
- Send email messages after comment was submitted
- Admin Dashboard – Recent Comments source
- How to use filter on comment submission/insert
- Styling Admin comments in WP 3.1.3
- Prevent users to delete comments from trash
- How do I add custom field to Admin comment form and display
- How to prevent users/authors from seing IP/email of new commentators?
- Comments counter only for Authors Posts
- where can I find the missing comments in my wordpress dashboard?
- How to disable the “Your site has updated to WordPress x.y.z” admin email?
- How can I see whether a commenter has subscribed to be notified of replies / other comments to a post
- How to enable reply button on mostly deeply-nested comments? [closed]
- How to ‘If Author’ Comments Check
- Identify and display the fact that user is admin next to username in comment section
- edit-comments.php in Admin – how to change ‘Comments’ title?
- New User Notification – Setting Email
- Query comments with non-empty ‘author_url’ value on Admin Comments Screen
- Customize the new comment notifications sent to the post author after the comment is approved
- How do I comment out a block of tags in XML?
- R: Comment out block of code
- Why do I get comment spam even with Akismet and Captcha?
- What tools are available for managing/writing to WordPress? [closed]
- How to rearrange fields in comment_form()
- setting comments off as default for pages and custom post types?
- Disable email notification after change of password
- Is it possible to pull comments from facebook into your blog?
- Alert Email when any Post or Page is Changed
- Find out which moderator approved comment?
- Filtering the Admin Comments List to Show Only Comments from the Current User?
- Non-threaded comment replies with link to original comment
- Approve comment hook?
- Commenting in user profile page?
- How to change “You must be logged in to post a comment.”
- comment_post_ID 0 (cannot remove from dashboard)
- Disable comments on all posts/pages
- How do I delete all comments from a specific old blog post?
- Removing the “Website” Field from Comments and Replies?
- Stop WordPress redirecting comment-page-1 to the post page?
- Importing old Disqus comments into WordPress
- How to add a class to the comment submit button?
- How to wrap submit button of comment form with div
- How to enable comments for pending and draft posts?
- Using WordPress’ WYSIWYG for comments
- Enable Submit Comment Without Page Reload (Using Ajax)?
- What for is the table “wp_commentmeta” exactly?
- Getting Post Comments for post ID using WP_Query() and a Custom Loop?
- Add option to disable comments on a per posts basis?
- Resetting comment count
- When importing – failed to import: Invalid post type feedback
- Redirect user to a custom url after submitting the comment
- Paginate result set from $wpdb->get_results()
- Change Comment Author Display Name
- Would switching to InnoDB from MyISAM improve performance of comments table?
- Custom comment type based on thread level
- How to load and show comments with AJAX instead of pagination?
- Linking to Page Showing Only Comments Without Parent Post
- Comment Reply javascript
- How do we remove the H3 tag for the reply-title I.D
- Comments not appearing at all
- comments reply script not working
- How to display comment form error messages in the same page
- Custom admin email for new user registration
- Send Admin Emails to Multiple Email Addresses
- Sends out email to admin
- Overriding the default WP Multisite notification e-mail
- 3 moderators to approve comment
- Customizing the Subject Field in WordPress’ Notification Emails?
- How to deal with small scale comment spam on small commercial sites? [closed]