Building an email signup form. Where should the information be saved in the DB?

There are multiple storage mechanisms in WP so it can be bit tricky to pick one and sometimes there is no single right choice.

Let’s examine your criteria for storage:

  • persistent (you don’t want data just evaporating)
  • processable (you want to export it and probably navigate)
  • simple to implement (you don’t want go building something (semi)custom just for the heck of it)
  • extensible (in case you want to capture more data down the road and such)

As for me the best storage to satisfy these condition would be using custom post type. It comes with a lot of functionality out of the box (like admin interface), requires no messing with storage (custom tables or whatever) and is perfectly suited to store arbitrary information in custom fields.