Excess elements of scalar initializer for pointer to array of ints

The two are only partly equivalent. The difference being that:

static char daytab[2][13] = {
    {0, 31, 28, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}, 
    {0, 31, 29, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}
};

declares a two-dimensional array, which includes setting aside space for the array and ensuring that daytab references that memory. However:

static char (*daytab)[13] = {
    {0, 31, 28, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}, 
    {0, 31, 29, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}
};

…only declares a pointer. So you’re trying to initialize a pointer with an array initializer, which doesn’t work as expected. There is no array; there’s no memory set aside for an array. What happens instead is that the first number in your initializer is assigned to the pointer daytab, and the compiler generates a warning to let you know you’ve specified a lot of additional values that are just discarded. Since the first number in your initializer is 0, you’re just setting daytab to NULL in a rather verbose way.

So if you want to do this sort of initialization, use the first version — it decays to the same pointer type that you explicitly declare in the second version, so you can use it the same way. The second version, with the array pointer, is needed when you wish to dynamically allocate the array or get a reference to another array that already exists.

So you can do this:

static char arr[2][3] = { { 1, 2, 3 }, { 4, 5, 6 } };
static char (*ptr)[3] = NULL;

ptr = arr;

…and then use ptr and arr interchangeably. Or this:

static char (*ptr)[3] = NULL;

ptr = malloc(2 * sizeof(*ptr));

…to get a dynamically allocated 2-dimensional array (not an array of pointers to 1D arrays, but a real 2D array). Of course, it’s not initialized in that case.

The “equivalence” of the two variations just means that the 2D array, when it decays to a pointer to its first element, decays to the type of pointer declared in the second variation. Once the pointer version is actually pointed at an array, the two are equivalent. But the 2D array version sets up memory for the array, where the pointer declaration doesn’t… and the pointer can be assigned a new value (pointed at a different array) where the 2D array variable cannot.

In C99 you can do this, though (if not static at least):

char (*daytab)[13] = (char [][13]){
    {0, 31, 28, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}, 
    {0, 31, 29, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31, 31, 30, 31, 30, 31}
};

Related Posts:

  1. Returning an array using C
  2. Pointer to 2D arrays in C
  3. char *array and char array[]
  4. C pointers and arrays: [Warning] assignment makes pointer from integer without a cast
  5. What does ** do in C language?
  6. How to make an array with a dynamic size? General usage of dynamic arrays (maybe pointers too)?
  7. How to initialize array to 0 in C?
  8. Warning: assignment from incompatible pointer type
  9. How to properly malloc for array of struct in C
  10. Initialization from incompatible pointer type warning when assigning to a pointer
  11. Convert char array to a int number in C
  12. What is the difference between char array and char pointer in C?
  13. How to copy a char array in C?
  14. Why do I get “cast from pointer to integer of different size” error?
  15. C subscripted value is neither array nor pointer nor vector when assigning an array element value
  16. struct has no member named
  17. Initializing array of structures
  18. How to empty a char array?
  19. What is the difference between array and enum in C ?
  20. Can I create an Array of Char pointers in C?
  21. What exactly is meant by “de-referencing a NULL pointer”?
  22. How to allocate array of pointers for strings by malloc in C?
  23. Difference between char *argv[] and char **argv for the second argument to main()
  24. Warning: comparison of distinct pointer types
  25. Realloc Invalid Pointer in C
  26. The difference between char * and char[] [duplicate]
  27. typedef fixed length array
  28. C: warning: excess elements in array initializer; near initialization for ‘xxx’ ; expects ‘char *’, but has type ‘int’
  29. Initializing 2D char array in C
  30. Pointer to a string in C?
  31. How do I check if a string contains a certain character?
  32. Using pointer to char array, values in that array can be accessed?
  33. Arrow operator (->) usage in C
  34. Return array in a function
  35. What does “dereferencing” a pointer mean?
  36. What is the difference between const int*, const int * const, and int const *?
  37. How do I create an array of strings in C?
  38. Invalid pointer error on invoking free() after malloc in C
  39. How do I create an array of strings in C?
  40. How do you pass a function as a parameter in C?
  41. How do you pass a function as a parameter in C?
  42. C free(): invalid pointer
  43. Finding the length of a Character Array in C
  44. Return char[]/string from a function
  45. C++: Expression must have a constant value when declaring array inside function
  46. Valgrind: Invalid read of size 1
  47. Zero an array in C code
  48. Passing an array by reference in C?
  49. Excess elements in char array initializer error
  50. Warning: return from incompatible pointer type in C
  51. How to do scanf for single char in C
  52. Break statement not within loop or switch in C
  53. C++ array assign error: invalid array assignment
  54. Where is the C auto keyword used?
  55. Bind failed: Address already in use
  56. What is stdin in C language?
  57. How to pass 2D array (matrix) in a function in C?
  58. Iterate through a C array
  59. How to compile makefile using MinGW?
  60. Mapping a numeric range onto another
  61. Why are hexadecimal numbers prefixed with 0x?
  62. too many arguments for format [-Wformat-extra-args]
  63. cast to pointer from integer of different size, pthread code
  64. Invalid type argument of unary ‘*’ (have ‘int’) Error in C
  65. Where to find the complete definition of off_t type?
  66. printf not printing to screen
  67. Still Reachable Leak detected by Valgrind
  68. Assembly x86 – “leave” Instruction
  69. What is signed integer overflow?
  70. When to use const char * and when to use const char []
  71. Double pointer array in c++
  72. What do numbers using 0x notation mean?
  73. Convert Little Endian to Big Endian
  74. error C2371: ‘functionname’ redefinition: different basic types
  75. How to write to a file using open() and printf()?
  76. note: previous implicit declaration of ‘point_forward’ was here
  77. getc() vs fgetc() – What are the major differences?
  78. C char array initialization
  79. typedef struct pointer definition
  80. Tokenizing strings in C
  81. char array not assignable
  82. How to format strings using printf() to get equal length in the output
  83. Why and when to use static structures in C programming?
  84. Where does linux store my syslog?
  85. Example of waitpid() in use?
  86. Is C++ Array passed by reference or by pointer?
  87. Can a function return two values?
  88. How to know what the ‘errno’ means?
  89. Split string with multiple delimiters using strtok in C
  90. Printf was not declared in this scope
  91. warning: missing terminating ” character [enabled by default]
  92. How to free memory from char array in C
  93. Can I get Unix’s pthread.h to compile in Windows?
  94. GCC: Array type has incomplete element type
  95. FFT in a single C-file 
  96. Process exited with return value 3221225477
  97. malloc(sizeof(int)) vs malloc(sizeof(int *)) vs (int *)malloc(sizeof(int))
  98. %p Format specifier in c
  99. Convert Char to String in C
  100. Array of Linked Lists C++

Leave a Comment