Is possible to add post-formats to custom-post-type?

For those coming here because of the title of the question:

If you have a look at Post Formats at the Codex you’ll see that

[…] New formats cannot be introduced by themes or even plugins. […]

Which kills you’re option 2.

Also have a look at this: Custom Post Formats

For your apparent actual question:
It really depends on how much they differ. But if they have different taxonomies and different data fields I’d say have separate post types.

Related Posts:

  1. How to set a default format for a custom post type?
  2. How do I add a new custom post format?
  3. Custom Post Formats for Custom Post Types
  4. Custom post types vs post formats : future-proofing – is one less “future proof” than another?
  5. Different post format options per custom post type?
  6. How can I add dropdown widget/box to admin post page?
  7. Strip shortcode from specific post types (formats)
  8. Apply post formats to a specific post type only?
  9. WordPress As A Shared Items Collection
  10. WordPress export tool doesn’t export post-format value of custom post type?
  11. Registering different Post Formats for Blog Post and CPT
  12. URL of a custom post type’s post format archive?
  13. How can I add a filter to a particular post format?
  14. Is it possible to filter the display name for post formats for display in the Formats meta box?
  15. Understanding Post Formats/Custom Post types Etc
  16. Post format or Type for List Type Posts
  17. Getting Twitter Content on My Blog
  18. Use different post formats on different post types
  19. How does one go about converting custom post type to post format?
  20. Archive of post format for Custom Post Type
  21. Why is my custom post type shown in the wrong place?
  22. CPT unsaved draft gives error 404 – when Post Formats support enabled
  23. Pagination not working with custom loop
  24. Advanced search form with filters for custom taxonomies and custom fields
  25. WordPress 3.3 custom post type with /%postname%/ permastruct?
  26. Custom Taxonomy’s Label to change the text appearing in Appearance > Menu
  27. Have different search results template depending of custom post type searched
  28. Why does a custom post type need the ”hierarchical’ args setting?
  29. How do I programmatically add items of content to a custom post type?
  30. order by meta_value serialized array
  31. bulk Update post_meta with default values
  32. WP_Query pagination using only numbers instead of /page/1 on URL
  33. How do I set the content for a post of a particular CPT?
  34. Output the slug and name of a CPT single post taxonomy term
  35. Slug for standard post post_type
  36. Custom post types – show specific posts
  37. Paginate_links links not working accordingly to how I do query the page
  38. Parent page using wp_dropdown_pages and multiple post types
  39. Updating post title using wp_update_post
  40. Remove parent from custom post type
  41. Add nonexisting pages to navigation
  42. How to add plugin custom field to custom post type?
  43. Multiple post type queries (with specific arguments for each)
  44. Troubles with making a custom template for posts
  45. Custom Post Type and Labels
  46. related posts – pulling tags from a specific post type
  47. WP 3.0.5 – Custom posts matching 2 taxonomies
  48. Custom Post Type Loop within Shortcode
  49. How can you handle rewrite rules for custom post types with option to filter on custom taxonomy terms?
  50. Custom query works but returns “Undefined Offset: 0”
  51. Query Multiple Meta Values and display only when it has both meta values
  52. Custom post type permalink returns bad url
  53. Custom Post Types – Change order of menu items
  54. What template files do I need to customise custom-category-term-links rather than fall back on archive.php?
  55. WordPress 3.5 Media Uploader – Only allow 1 upload and certain file types
  56. wp_update_term_count_now doesn’t work with a custom post type?
  57. Custom post types as sub menu pages and role capabilities issue
  58. Can I update all my posts inside my custom post type by creating a simple function
  59. Troubles with acf/save_post and WP_Query
  60. Add custom field in comments form
  61. WordPress request fiter order by related post’s post_title
  62. How to use manage_$post_type_posts_columns with underscore in post type?
  63. How to specify a template for a path like http://example.com/something?
  64. Template to list categories in custom taxonomy
  65. Categories and tags for custom post types
  66. WordPress 3.9 not using custom template
  67. Display different information of a custom post type
  68. uploading problem of wordpress theme
  69. How to add a sub directory to WordPress single posts without affecting other post types?
  70. How do you make a list and list item relation if custom post types?
  71. Before saving post hook
  72. Two custom post types divided in two columns inside a bootstrap carousel
  73. Getting array_merge(): Argument #2 is not an array on register_post_type
  74. Is it possible to sort metabox teaxtarea values?
  75. How can I relate custom post types?
  76. Display author box on just certain category posts?
  77. Tag template not returning posts [closed]
  78. Custom Post Type Causes Error: Warning: call_user_func_array()
  79. Permalink with hierarchy of Custom Post Types
  80. How do I set a post slug automatically based on taxonomy?
  81. Get a list of custom post type (property) when clicked on custom taxonomy 1 (rent or sale) from custom taxonomy 2 (city) page
  82. How to divide Subcategories into pages of parent category wordpress
  83. Is there any filter to add a custom attribute to the tag in admin panel?
  84. Custom post type category returns null
  85. Tell wordpress to show a single page instead of an archive page
  86. Post display in separate page [duplicate]
  87. Create dynamic logo carousel without using any plugin
  88. Delete Post by User
  89. Only show current category post
  90. WordPress Contents Migration
  91. Test for post type in request filter?
  92. Have two (permalinks) urls for a same custom post type
  93. If taxonomy show class of active
  94. Query Posts From Multiple Post Types
  95. Custom Post Types (Changing post style based on category)
  96. How to loop through custom posts in admin edit screen
  97. Notices when submitting custom post type from front-end
  98. show custom post’s post in two different divs [duplicate]
  99. querying to custom field over ACF REST API
  100. Fatal Error WordPress Custom Post Type UI + WPML